India's market regulator hits PwC with 2-year auditing ban

India's market regulator hits PwC with 2-year auditing ban

Previously PwC, had made two attempts to settle the case through the consent mechanism.

Over nine years after the Rs 7136 crore Satyam Scam rocked India, Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi), late on Wednesday night (January 10) banned worldwide auditing giant Pricewaterhouse Coopers (PwC) and its network entities from issuing audit certificates to any listed company in India for a period of two years.

While making it clear that it will appeal against the Sebi order next week, Price Waterhouse (PW) also comforted around 3,000 auditors, saying that it will take care of their interest and there was no reason to worry.

However, it added it has learnt the lessons of Satyam and invested "heavily" over the last nine years in "building a robust and high quality audit practice".

"It is possibly the beginning of the end of the Price Waterhouse's auditing business in India as the clients will turn elsewhere. Though a two-year ban seems a bit harsh, it could deter the Big Four firms from expanding in India and affect their momentum", said Amarjeet Chopra, former president of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India. The Satyam promoters inflated revenue and profits to showcase a healthy picture of the company when PwC was its auditor. The appointment of an auditor requires a shareholder resolution and board approval. "Satyam was egregious even by the standards of Indian accounting", said R. Narayanaswamy, professor of finance and control at the Indian Institute of Management Bangalore.

Sebi said PW firms benefited from the relationship with Satyam Computers by having collectively received a fee of Rs 23.31 core during 2000-08.

SEBI had in February 2009 issued a show-cause notice to Price Waterhouse, among other entities, after it emerged that Satyam's accounts were falsified. Companies may also not want to go through a removal process and appoint a new auditor, especially if the appointment is still fresh.

"The audit work for the current financial year will go on until September-October, but employees have nothing to worry about".

More news: Schlumberger Limited (NYSE: SLB) - Explore Volume Patterns For Some Important Insights
More news: Kratos Defense & Security Solutions (NASDAQ:KTOS) Earns News Sentiment Rating of 0.16
More news: Kris Bryant, Chicago Cubs Reach Arbitration Agreement

Price Waterhouse has, expectedly, rejected the charges brought out against it by Sebi while expressing its disappointment on the ban. The Corporate Affairs Ministry (MCA) will examine SEBI's order, Union Minister PP Chaudhary said on January 11.

Many of these companies have large balance sheets, and comprise 4.4% of the 1,692 companies listed on the National Stock Exchange, India's largest exchange by transaction value.

"Why should they resign?"

The audit firm stands a better chance of getting a stay if it approaches the Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT) instead of a court, said Sandeep Parekh, founder, Finsec Law Advisors and a former SEBI law officer. The event shocked the Indian markets and triggered investigations by several agencies.

The top global accountancy firms include PwC, Deloitte, EY and KPMG.

Sebi noted that the order would not impact audit assignments relating to the fiscal year 2017-18 undertaken by the firms forming part of the PwC network.

The affair, however, may make it hard for Price Waterhouse to win new clients because of the damage to its reputation, and the uncertainty that a court proceeding for a stay order would bring.

Related Articles

  • IShares MSCI China Small-Cap (ECNS) Rises 0.86% for Jan 12

    IShares MSCI China Small-Cap (ECNS) Rises 0.86% for Jan 12

    The institutional investor owned 59,358 shares of the exchange traded fund's stock after selling 12,824 shares during the period. Williams %R is a popular technical indicator created by Larry Williams to help identify overbought and oversold situations.
    Pruitt ready to solely focus on coaching Vols

    Pruitt ready to solely focus on coaching Vols

    Nine of Georgia's defensive starters from the Rose Bowl game played for Pruitt at Georgia during his two seasons in 2014 and 2015. And after splitting duties between Alabama and Tennessee for a month, Pruitt belongs exclusively to the Volunteers now.
    NewsAlert: Canada launches global trade complaint vs U.S.  over use of duties

    NewsAlert: Canada launches global trade complaint vs U.S. over use of duties

    Meantime, the new duties will also put many local newspapers at risk of failing, according to USA newspaper coalitions. Kursman said Norpac was alone in its challenge because production margins are "razor thin".
  • United States  officials raid 7-Eleven stores amid crackdown on illegal

    United States officials raid 7-Eleven stores amid crackdown on illegal

    Eight of the accused wound up pleading guilty and were ordered to pay more than $2.6 million in back wages. He said there would be more employment audits and investigations, though there is no numerical goal.
    Trump To Cut Off Pakistan From US Aid For Terror Support

    Trump To Cut Off Pakistan From US Aid For Terror Support

    Trump wrote further: "They give safe haven to the terrorists we hunt in Afghanistan, with little help". Senator Rand Paul said on Twitter he would lead the charge in the Senate to end aid to Pakistan.
    GKN plots break-up after rejecting £7bn takeover offer

    GKN plots break-up after rejecting £7bn takeover offer

    The town's ironworks supplied rails to railways in the United Kingdom and overseas , making it the world's largest by 1845. This is before accounting for the previously announced substantial write-offs in the North American Aerospace business.
  • Trump calls nations 'shithole' in White House talks

    Trump calls nations 'shithole' in White House talks

    Trump's meek denial came during a series of tweets blasting an immigration deal reached by six bipartisan senators on Thursday . Durbin said in his statement Friday that he and others in his bipartisan group will continue pressing for a DACA deal.
    Rob Lowe slams Bella Thorne

    Rob Lowe slams Bella Thorne

    Lowe took to Instagram with a tweet Thorne posted on January 10 that read, "f**k u 101 to santa barbra". Mod Sun , on his Instagram Stories page, said to Rob , "I thought you were cool, man.
    Utah Jazz's Rodney Hood gets ejected, smacks fans phone out of hand

    Utah Jazz's Rodney Hood gets ejected, smacks fans phone out of hand

    But it's also kind of inappropriate, surely, to start filming an athlete when he's clearly going to be steaming angry. Bleacher Report noted that Hood can probably expect a call from the league office for his, hm, insouciance.
  • How Many Rio Tinto plc (NYSE:RIO)'s Analysts Are Bearish?

    How Many Rio Tinto plc (NYSE:RIO)'s Analysts Are Bearish?

    Take a broader look now, Rio Tinto plc's performance year to date is 5.31%, giving you a current mood of this particular equity. SunTrust maintained Sensata Technologies Holding N.V. (NYSE:ST) on Wednesday, October 11 with "Buy" rating.
    Halliburton Company (NYSE: HAL) - Top RSI Trades for Today

    Halliburton Company (NYSE: HAL) - Top RSI Trades for Today

    Charles Paquelet decreased its stake in Halliburton Co ( HAL ) by 27.5% based on its latest 2017Q3 regulatory filing with the SEC. Of course, these surface-level price movements don't tell us much about the direction that VNTV may be headed in the future.
    John Williams Will Score Star Wars: Episode IX

    John Williams Will Score Star Wars: Episode IX

    This would certainly be taking the idea to an extreme, but we're certainly led to believe that what Luke does is extreme. According to Rian Johnson , Kylo didn't know it was destroyed.