Appeals court: Woman's defamation suit vs. Trump can proceed

Appeals court: Woman's defamation suit vs. Trump can proceed

In a move that could have big implications for the much-investigaed ex-Celebrity Apprentice host, a NY state appeals court today shut down Trump's ongoing desire to dodge Summer Zervos' legal action in its affirmation of a lower court ruling that POTUS can't get out of the case just because he is in the Oval Office.

The decision means that President Trump may have to sit for a sworn deposition, which is now scheduled for June. A deposition has been scheduled for some time before the end of June.

A panel of NY appellate judges issued its ruling Thursday in a case brought by Summer Zervos in which Trump accused her - and numerous other women - of being liars for alleging that he sexually harassed them.

The decision may allow Zervos' lawyers to question Trump under oath about whether he defamed her by calling her a liar after she accused him of sexual misconduct.

Two of the five judges on the panel dissented in part. But the NY appeals court said the clause in no way grants Trump such immunity. "It merely identified a potential constitutional concern".

Zervos's lawyer, Marianne Wang, said in a statement to ABC News that they were "very pleased" at the court's decision. "We look forward to proving that Ms. Zervos told the truth about Defendant's unwanted sexual groping and holding him accountable for his malicious lies".

Trump's lawyer, Marc Kasowitz, said he planned to appeal to New York's highest court.

More news: Sterling headed for best week since January after Brexit votes
More news: Heartache in Toronto in wake of deadly New Zealand mosque shootings
More news: James Gunn returning to direct ‘Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3’

Trump's legal team argued that the U.S. Constitution immunizes him from state court lawsuits arising from his private conduct before he took office.

In statements to the media in 2016 and then in her January 2017-filed complaint, Zervos claimed Trump sexually assaulted her twice in 2007. Trump denied the allegations.

Lawyers in another case against Mr. Trump may also received a boost. Numerous allegations about misconduct at the Trump Foundation were first reported by The Washington Post in 2016.

The main crux of Renwick's opinion centered on what she said was a poor reading of the Constitution's Supremacy Clause by Trump's legal team. Among them: James said that the foundation's board, which was legally required to oversee the charity's spending, had not met since 1999. It seeks shorter-term bans on charity service for Trump's children Eric, Ivanka and Donald Jr., who were all members of the foundation's board. Zervos sued for defamation.

Trump also faced a defamation claim by adult film actress Stormy Daniels in her lawsuit over a hush money agreement. That lawsuit was dismissed by a federal judge in October. "The result the Supreme Court reached in Jones. may well have been entirely correct".

Mr Trump also republished on Twitter a post calling Zervos' accusations a "hoax".

Related Articles

  • Australia's 2-year ODI losing streak ends in New Delhi

    Australia's 2-year ODI losing streak ends in New Delhi

    Usman Khawaja bagged the Man of the Series and the Man of the Match at Delhi for his phenomenal show with the bat. He's now also the batsman to score most runs against India in a five-match ODI series against India.
    No release for other Kim Jong-nam accused

    No release for other Kim Jong-nam accused

    Kim Jong-nam was assassinated with liquid VX nerve agent at Kuala Lumpur airport in February 2017. She thanked the Party, State and the Vietnamese Embassy in Malaysia for their help and support.
    Oakland Raiders Release WR Jordy Nelson

    Oakland Raiders Release WR Jordy Nelson

    The only other quarterback employed by the Raiders is Nathan Peterman , who's signed to a reserve/future contract. After the acquisitions of wide receivers Antonio Brown and Tyrell Williams , Nelson seemingly became expendable.
  • European clubs say will boycott FIFA’s Club World Cup

    European clubs say will boycott FIFA’s Club World Cup

    The increase in teams will see the tournament feature 80 matches instead of the 64 used in a traditional 32-team World Cup. He also revealed FIFA's decision to launch a revamped world club competition that includes 24 teams starting 2021.
    UK opposition Labour: lawmakers must reject PM May's Brexit deal

    UK opposition Labour: lawmakers must reject PM May's Brexit deal

    Some of her colleagues around the Cabinet table think it shows she has to tack to a closer deal with the EU. Tariffs would be maintained to protect some industries, including agriculture.

    Shootings reported at mosques in Christchurch, New Zealand

    Breivik is a right-wing Norwegian extremist who killed 77 people in Oslo and a nearby island in 2011. Constitution, and claimed that attempts to take away guns in the U.S. will lead to a civil war.
  • ‘Absolutely his intention’: Christchurch gunman planned further attacks, had other firearms

    ‘Absolutely his intention’: Christchurch gunman planned further attacks, had other firearms

    Two other people have been apprehended and are being questioned about what role, if any, they had in the attacks . Tarrant, 28, flashed a white power gesture as he appeared in court Saturday charged with one count of murder.
    O'Brien back for Ireland as Beirne makes Six Nations bow

    O'Brien back for Ireland as Beirne makes Six Nations bow

    Kearney has overcome a calf injury to take position at full-back pushing Jordan Larmour to the bench. Rory Best will lead the traditional eve of match Captain's Run at the Principality Stadium.
    Foreigners among those killed and wounded in New Zealand mosque attacks

    Foreigners among those killed and wounded in New Zealand mosque attacks

    Currently, New Zealand restricts the purchase of "military-style semi-automatic weapons" to those 18 or older. He also had more assault weapons in the trunk of his vehicle , along with what appeared to be explosives.
  • Harden shrugs off loss; D'Antoni warns of trouble

    Harden shrugs off loss; D'Antoni warns of trouble

    "For us, he's not the main focus because we are really trying to take away 3s and make them score in the paint", Capela said. As Beyonce, a Houston native, sang on "6 Inch", (although not at all related to sports) " Come back, come back, come back ".
    Woman awarded $29M in Johnson & Johnson talcum cancer case

    Woman awarded $29M in Johnson & Johnson talcum cancer case

    It is one of the most mysterious cancers , and it's not clear why asbestos travels to ovarian tissues, but it is well-documented. The company said in a statement , shared with PEOPLE, that they plan to appeal the ruling.
    Celebrate Pi Day with These Baltimore Pizza Specials

    Celebrate Pi Day with These Baltimore Pizza Specials

    Salt and Straw: The popular artisan ice cream shop has a pie infused flavor that's ideal for Pi Day: wild foraged berry slab pie. California Pizza Kitchen is selling not pizza, surprisingly, but a slice of key lime pie for $3.14 Thursday.